• Menu
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Uncover Colorado Logo

  • Blog
  • Activities
    • Year-round
      • Brewery Tours
      • Casinos & Gaming
      • Caves
      • Colorado Brands
      • Escape Rooms
      • Federal Lands
      • Food & Dining
      • Ghost Towns
      • Gondola & Chairlifts
      • Hot Springs
      • Lakes
      • Landmarks
      • Mine Tours
      • Mountains
      • Museums
      • Paintball
      • Performing Arts
      • Public Parks
      • Rivers
      • Scenic Drives
      • Sightseeing Tours
      • Shopping
      • Sports Teams
      • State Parks
      • Train Rides
      • Transportation
      • Winery Tours
      • Wildlife
      • Zip Lines & Aerial Parks
    • Spring, Summer & Fall
      • Amusement Parks
      • ATV Rentals
      • Biking
      • Boating
      • Camping
      • Drive-In Theaters
      • Fishing
      • Golf Courses
      • Hiking
      • Horseback Riding
      • Jeep Rentals
      • Rock Climbing
      • Tubing & Paddling
      • Waterfalls
      • Whitewater Rafting
    • Winter
      • Cross Country Skiing
      • Dog Sledding
      • Ice Climbing
      • Ice Fishing
      • Ice Skating
      • Skiing & Snowboarding
      • Sleigh Rides
      • Snow Tubing
      • Snowbiking
      • Snowmobiling
      • Snowshoeing
  • Events
    • January
    • February
    • March
    • April
    • May
    • June
    • July
    • August
    • September
    • October
    • November
    • December
  • Lodging
    • Budget Hotels
    • Historic Hotels
    • Luxury Hotels
    • Bed & Breakfasts
    • Boutique Hotels
    • Cabins & Glamping
    • Casinos w/ Lodging
    • Hot Spring w/ Lodging
    • Wineries w/ Lodging
    • Best Hotels
    • Dude Ranches
    • Campgrounds
  • Towns
  • Trip Planner
  • Search
  • Blog
  • Activities
  • Events
  • Lodging
  • Towns
  • Trip Planner
North Fork of the South Platte River Near Buffalo Creek, Colorado
North Fork of the South Platte River, near Buffalo Creek, CO. Photo by: Jeffrey Beall

8 Top Fishing Spots by Bailey & Fairplay

August 5, 2021 By //  by Patrick McGuire

FacebookTwitter

The largest towns of Park County, Bailey and Fairplay are both surrounded by immense peaks, lush evergreen forests, and excellent fishing opportunities. From vast mountain reservoirs to pleasant streams brimming with trout, these two towns happen to be close to fishing spots so promising that anglers from around the world travel to them.

Fairplay and Bailey are located forty-five minutes apart on Highway 285. Here’s a list of nearby recommendations if you’re in town looking for a great place to fish:

Antero Reservoir

Antero Reservoir Fishing Colorado
Antero Reservoir fishing. Photo by: Alan Schmierer

Located in central South Park more than an hour’s drive from Bailey, this large reservoir is a solid fishing destination known for Rainbow Trout, Brown Trout, and Snake River Cutthroat Trout. As with most bodies of water this big, sizable monsters are known to lurk deep in these waters, like the 18.5-pound Cutbow Trout that was caught here by an angler named Frank Stack.

You’ll absolutely find prettier bodies of water in the area, but this spot still delivers excellent views of the surrounding mountains. Plus, Antero Reservoir has amenities like boat ramps, bathrooms, campsites, and picnic areas, and it offers ice fishing in the winter.

North Fork Fork of the South Platte River

North Fork of the South Platte River, Pine, Colorado
North Fork of the South Platte River, Pine Valley Ranch Park. Photo by: Tom Wilberding

Due to unpredictable water flows and the lack of bugs in the area, the trout in large sections of this river are sparse and don’t typically grow to be too big. However, outside of Bailey there are said to be a couple of spots where 8″-14″ fish are common.

The lower section of the South Platte River below Foxton Road is also promising. This obviously isn’t the section of river you seek out if you’re a die-hard angler looking to catch the biggest trout of your life. However, it’s a great close-to-home option if you’re learning how to fly-fish or want to non-stressful place to cast out your line.

Spinney Mtn Res, Dream Stream, and Eleven Mile Res

Eleven Mile Reservoir Fishing Colorado
Fishing on the shores of Eleven Mile Reservoir, South Park, Colo. Photo by: Cody Wellons

At almost an hour and a half away from Bailey, it takes a bit of a time investment to reach these fishing spots, which are located in central South Park between Hartsel and Lake George. But when you learn that this area is internationally famous for trout fishing, you’ll quickly realize the drive is completely worth it.

Much of this area has earned Colorado’s famed “Gold Medal” designation for fishing, which means that the water here is proven to be bursting with exceptionally vibrant and sizable populations of trout. Spinney Mountain Reservoir is just one of a few select bodies of water that has earned the title, while the section of the South Platte River (aka the “Dream Stream) stretching from here to the Eleven Mile Reservoir has also won the designation.

Eleven Mile Reservoir hasn’t earned the Gold Medal nod, but it’s a promising place to fish nonetheless. This hallowed fishing destination is protected by state regulations, so make sure you know the local rules before fishing here.

Wellington Lake

Fishing Boat Wellington Lake Sunset Colorado
Sunset at Wellington Lake. Photo by: Rob Lee

This serene alpine lake sits 40 minutes southeast of Bailey. A privately owned 167-acre trophy fishery, Wellington Lake is stocked with Rainbow, Cutbow, Brown, Brook, Tiger, and Palomino Trout, and offers ice fishing during the winter. This spot is catch-and-release only, and an entrance fee is required.

The benefit of fishing here extends to inexperienced anglers looking for a promising place to get started, and those camping in the area who want to fish (fishing is included with the camping fee). Other strict rules apply while fishing here, like skipping live and artificial bait.

Upper Deer Creek and Craig Creek

Some of the creeks near Bailey offer stellar opportunities to catch trout. Located in the Pike National Forest, the section of the Upper Deer Creek northwest of Bailey past the Deer Creek Campground is said to hold sizable Brook and Brown Trout.

Craig Creek, which is located in the Lost Creek Wilderness west of town, is reportedly brimming with small brook trout. It takes five miles to access the creek and the fish here aren’t trophy material by any stretch of the imagination, but the opportunity to fish in such a serene and remote setting will be worth the hike for many anglers.

Tarryall Reservoir

Tarryall Reservoir Colorado
Tarryall Reservoir, Colo. Photo by: Michael Manginf

Located 20 minutes south of Jefferson (halfway between Bailey and Fairplay), this decently sized reservoir offers exciting fishing opportunities to everyone from experienced anglers to kids learning to fish for the first time. It’s a state wildlife area and the drive down on Count Road 77 is paved and pretty.

The surrounding streams are said to be great for fly-fishing, and nearby camping is ideal for families wanting to extend their fishing trips. Trout and Pike are the main offerings of fish you’ll find here.

Cheesman Lake

This reservoir offers an exciting array of fish to catch, including Rainbow, Brown, and Brook Trout, Smallmouth Bass, Kokanee Salmon, Yellow Perch, and Northern Pike. An hour south of town, it’s a large body of water immersed in a gorgeous natural setting, and you’ll be treated to steal views of the surrounding mountains and forests anywhere you cast here.

According to Colorado Parks and Wildlife, Cheesman Lake is “famous” for the size of trout it holds. You’ll find helpful amenities here, like bathrooms, hiking trails, and parking lots.

Alpine lakes at the Guanella Pass Summit

Accessing most of the stunning alpine lakes located high atop the summit of Guanella Pass isn’t as easy as showing up to a big reservoir to fish, but you’ll be handsomely rewarded for your trouble. For example, getting to the Silver Dollar and Murray Lakes requires a moderately difficult but short hike. In addition to the absolutely incredible panoramic mountain views you’ll be treated to here, there are often large and hungry trout lurking in these lakes waiting for their next meal.

Those are some of best places to fish around the towns of Bailey and Fairplay, Colorado. While your out fishing, considering posting up camp at one of these towns:

  • Read aboutย camping near Conifer, Pine, Bailey and Grant.
  • Read about theย camping near Fairplay and South Park.
Patrick McGuire

About Patrick McGuire

Patrick McGuire is a freelance writer and musician living in the mountain west.

FacebookTwitter

Join our Colorado travel community

Enter your email below and grab our free locals' guide and monthly what's up designed to help you live your Colorado life and uncover fun things to do. โ€”and never miss out again.

Previous Post: «Fly Fishing at Arkansas River Pueblo Colorado 9 Fishing Spots near Colorado Springs
Next Post: Things to do during a Westcliffe weekend image of westcliffe colorado»

Primary Sidebar

Join our Colorado travel community

Enter your email below and grab our free locals' guide and monthly what's up designed to help you live your Colorado life and uncover fun things to do. โ€”and never miss out again.

Nearby Colorado Fishing

  • All Fishing
  • Best Fishing
  • Gold Medal Waters
  • Native Fish
  • Aspen
  • Bailey and Fairplay
  • Boulder
  • Breckenridge
  • Colorado Springs
  • Crested Butte
  • Denver
  • Durango
  • Fort Collins
  • Grand Junction
  • Pueblo
  • South Fork
  • Telluride
  • Trinidad

Footer

Get In Touch

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Resources
  • Disclaimer
Facebook Instagram Pinterest Twitter

Disclosure: Uncover Colorado is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com.

Things To Do

  • Travel Blog
  • Colorado Activities
  • Colorado Events
  • Colorado Towns
  • Colorado Hotels
  • Colorado Restaurants
  • Colorado Transportation
  • Made in Colorado

Cheers! Mile High Happy Hour shares showcases Denver neighborhoods' restaurant happy hours.

Winter Activities

  • Federal Lands
  • Ghost Towns
  • Hot Springs
  • Ice Skating
  • Ski Resorts
  • Snow Tubing
  • State Parks
  • Train Rides

Copyright © 2023 ยท Uncover Colorado | Sitemap | Advertise